credit-based insurance score auto South Carolina and NC
A credit-based insurance score is a rating based fully or partly on a consumer's credit information, and insurers use that credit information, along with additional factors, when they underwrite and price a personal auto policy. [1] That rating is not the description USA.gov gives a consumer credit score. On a page last updated November 13, 2025, USA.gov says a credit score is a number creditors use to judge credit behavior, including how likely a person is to make payments on a loan. [2] South Carolina's Department of Insurance says credit scoring may be used in underwriting and in rating of policies. [3] North Carolina statute lets an insurer use credit scoring as the sole basis for a rate discount on noncommercial private passenger auto coverage, and it bars credit scoring as the sole basis for ending a policy in effect more than 60 days, or for consent-to-rate, unless risk factors in addition to the score are considered. [4]
What a credit-based insurance score is
The Insurance Information Institute uses two names for one tool. Insurance scores, also called credit-based insurance scores, are ratings based fully or partially on a consumer's credit information. Insurers use credit information together with additional factors to underwrite and price policies. The article calls the ratings confidential and says they are typically used for personal lines such as homeowners insurance and personal automobile insurance. [1] The page does not print an article date in the text reviewed here. The copyright line reads 2026. The definition is not a premium table.
A South Carolina consumer guide is plainer, and it is old enough to date. Department of Insurance Document Center view 7348 resolves to a file named Auto-Brochure-Rev-11-2012. In that guide, the department wrote that South Carolina state law allows insurers to use an insurance credit score as a rating factor. The guide calls an insurance credit score a number based on various financial, credit, and risk factors. It also says some companies offer discounts to consumers who have higher insurance credit scores. [5] The revision label in the file name is 11-2012, so treat those sentences as a 2012 explanation, not as a full list of the limits the department now posts for filers. This post does not re-teach mileage programs, youthful-driver steps, or liability minimums.
How this differs from a consumer credit score
USA.gov, last updated November 13, 2025, defines a credit score as a number that creditors use to determine credit behavior, including how likely a person is to make payments on a loan. [2] The same page says a high credit score can make it easier to get a loan, rent an apartment, or lower an insurance rate. [6]
North Carolina writes a third description, and it is a statutory definition. In G.S. 58-36-90, "credit score" means a score derived by using data from an individual's credit report in an algorithm, computer program, model, or similar process that reduces the data to a number or rating. [7] The section does not set a 300-to-850 scale, and it does not define the score as a forecast of loan payments. The General Assembly page shows amendments through session law 2022-46. [7]
What North Carolina allows and limits
G.S. 58-36-90 covers rating and underwriting of noncommercial private passenger motor vehicle insurance, and of residential property insurance. A noncommercial private passenger motor vehicle, in this section, is a private passenger motor vehicle that is neither insured under a commercial policy nor used for commercial purposes. [4]
Subsection (b) is the sole-basis rule. Insurers shall not use credit scoring as the sole basis for terminating an existing policy, or any coverage in an existing policy, or for subjecting a policy to consent to rate, without consideration of risk factors in addition to the score. Insurers may use credit scoring as the sole basis for discounting rates. For this subsection only, an existing policy means a policy that has been in effect for more than 60 days. [4] The section specifies consent to rate by pointing to G.S. 58-36-30(b), which this article does not restate. A policy inside the first 60 days is outside the "existing policy" definition, and the discount permission is not tied to that clock. [4]
If a credit report is used along with additional criteria to take an adverse action, the insurer must give the applicant or policyholder written notice, in a form the Commissioner has approved. Adverse action, in this section, includes a denial, a cancellation, an increase in any charge, or a reduction or unfavorable change in the terms of coverage or in the amount of insurance, for coverage already in place or applied for, in connection with underwriting. [8] The notice must state the specific reason. If the action was based on a credit score, it must describe the factors that were the primary influence on the score. It must give the name, address, and toll-free telephone number of the credit bureau that supplied the information. It must state the right to a free copy of the credit report from that bureau, and the right to challenge information in the report. [8]
A successful dispute can reopen the premium. If the dispute process the section cites in the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 U.S.C. 1681i(a)(5), determines that the credit information of a current insured was incorrect or incomplete, and the insurer receives notice of that determination from the consumer reporting agency or from the insured, the insurer must re-underwrite or re-rate within 30 days of receiving the notice. It must then make adjustments consistent with its underwriting guidelines. If premium was overpaid, the refund runs back to the shorter of the last 12 months of coverage or the actual policy period. [9]
What South Carolina posts about the score
The 2012 guide is the department's plain consumer sentence: state law allows an insurance credit score as a rating factor, the score is a number based on financial, credit, and risk factors, and some companies discount a higher score. [5]
Credit scoring may be used in underwriting and in rating of policies. [3] If it is used in rating, the specific criteria used to calculate the score must be filed with the department, and the filing must include loss experience justifying the applicable surcharge or rate credit. [10] Credit scoring will not be allowed as the sole factor on which an insurer decides not to insure an individual risk. [11] Rate filings must list the factors used to score individual risks, the methodology used to develop each factor, and the weight given to each factor. [12]
No-hit or no-score factors should equal the average policyholder's score. The stated intent is to set that factor at the same level as the average score in the insurer's book, so the factor is applied as if the insurance risk score did not apply. [13] A policyholder may request that a new score be ordered every twelve months. [14]
Absence of credit information, and how long reports are kept
Section 38-73-425 says absence of credit information may be used for underwriting only if the insurer presents information satisfactory to the director that the absence is related to the risk. The history line dates the section to 2004 Act No. 290, effective July 29, 2004. [15] Section 38-73-410 states that this casualty article applies to casualty insurance and to automobile insurance on risks or operations in the state. [16]
Section 38-73-325 uses the same absence sentence, and its history line also cites 2004 Act No. 290, effective July 29, 2004. [17] Section 38-73-310 states that the fire and allied lines article, where section 38-73-325 sits, does not apply to automobile insurance and does not apply to liability from the ownership, maintenance, or use of motor vehicles. [18] Section 38-73-325 is not the personal auto rule. [18] The filings page, by contrast, sets a no-hit or no-score factor equal to the average score in the book so the missing score does not itself move the rate. [13] That rating treatment is separate from the underwriting limit in section 38-73-425. [15]
Section 38-73-740 covers the file, not the math. All information, including investigative reports and credit reports, used to determine the classification or premium rates of a person applying for automobile insurance must be kept for at least three years from the application date. On request, the applicant may inspect the file. Copies must be furnished if the applicant pays the reproduction cost. [19]
The refusal-to-issue list does not name a credit score
Section 38-77-122(A)(1) says no insurer or agent shall refuse to issue an automobile insurance policy, as defined in section 38-77-30, because of any one or more of a stated list. The factors are age, sex, location of residence in the state, race, color, creed, national origin, ancestry, marital status, and income level. [20] A credit score is not on that list. The section history shows 2026 Act No. 176, effective May 18, 2026. The refuse-to-issue factors in the text posted with that amendment still do not name a credit score. [20]
Silence in that list is not authorization. Section 38-77-122 does not say an insurer may use a credit-based insurance score. The live permission language is on the 2012 guide and on the filings page, not in section 38-77-122. [5] [3]
Practical takeaways
- The Institute's credit-based insurance score is a rating from credit information used to price personal auto coverage. USA.gov's November 13, 2025 page calls a credit score a creditor's loan-payment number, and says a high score can lower an insurance rate. [1] [2] [6]
- North Carolina may let the score stand alone for a discount, and it may not let the score stand alone for terminating a policy in effect more than 60 days, or for consent-to-rate, unless additional risk factors are considered. [4]
- After a successful credit-report dispute, a North Carolina insurer has 30 days from notice to re-underwrite or re-rate, and it must refund an overpayment back to the shorter of 12 months or the policy period. Written notice is required when a credit report supports an adverse action. [8] [9]
- South Carolina's 2012 guide says state law allows an insurance credit score as a rating factor. The filings page allows scoring in underwriting and rating, bars it as the sole reason not to insure an individual risk, sets a no-hit factor at the book average, and allows a new-score request every twelve months. [5] [3] [11] [13] [14]
- Section 38-73-425 allows an underwriting use of missing credit information only if the insurer shows the director the absence relates to the risk, and section 38-73-410 places that section in the article that applies to automobile insurance. Section 38-73-325 repeats the absence sentence in an article that section 38-73-310 excludes from automobile insurance. Credit reports used to classify or price an application must be kept at least three years. [15] [16] [17] [18] [19]
- Section 38-77-122's refuse-to-issue list does not name a credit score. That silence is not permission. [20]
How we can help
Personal auto quotes in South Carolina and North Carolina can treat a credit file differently because each state writes its own limits, and each company files its own rating criteria. The personal insurance page describes the personal auto coverage we place.
Have more questions or want to get in touch?
Contact us and see personal insurance options.
Citations
- Insurance Information Institute, "Background on: Insurance scoring" (2026)
- USAGov, "Credit score" (2025-11-13)
- South Carolina Department of Insurance, "Property and Casualty, credit scoring position" (filings page)
- North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 58-36-90, subsection (b)" (amended through S.L. 2022-46)
- South Carolina Department of Insurance, "Auto-Brochure-Rev-11-2012" (2012)
- USAGov, "Credit score" (2025-11-13)
- North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 58-36-90, credit score definition" (amended through S.L. 2022-46)
- North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 58-36-90, adverse-action notice" (amended through S.L. 2022-46)
- North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 58-36-90, disputed credit information" (amended through S.L. 2022-46)
- South Carolina Department of Insurance, "Property and Casualty, rating-filing condition" (filings page)
- South Carolina Department of Insurance, "Property and Casualty, sole-factor limit" (filings page)
- South Carolina Department of Insurance, "Property and Casualty, filed factors and weights" (filings page)
- South Carolina Department of Insurance, "Property and Casualty, no-hit factor" (filings page)
- South Carolina Department of Insurance, "Property and Casualty, new score request" (filings page)
- South Carolina Legislature, "Section 38-73-425" (effective July 29, 2004)
- South Carolina Legislature, "Section 38-73-410" (current code)
- South Carolina Legislature, "Section 38-73-325" (effective July 29, 2004)
- South Carolina Legislature, "Section 38-73-310" (current code)
- South Carolina Legislature, "Section 38-73-740" (current code)
- South Carolina Legislature, "Section 38-77-122" (amendment effective May 18, 2026)